Dad beamed at her like she’d just announced a cure for cancer. “That’s my girl—always landing on her feet.”

I took another bite of pot roast, trying to swallow down the familiar feeling of being second best. Some things never change, I thought, watching my parents hang on Sarah’s every word.

The call from Sarah came on a Tuesday morning. I was at my desk reviewing marketing reports when my phone lit up with her name. I almost let it go to voicemail—our conversations were usually brief and awkward—but something made me answer.

“Karen,” her voice had that sugary sweetness she only used when she wanted something. “I’m having my baby shower next weekend at Mom and Dad’s. I’d really love it if you could come.”

The invitation caught me off guard. The last real conversation we’d had was at James’s funeral, and even then she’d seemed distracted and uncomfortable.

“Are you sure?” I asked, unable to hide my surprise. I could count on one hand the number of times Sarah had voluntarily included me in anything.

“Of course.” She laughed, the sound oddly forced. “You’re my only sister. It wouldn’t be right without you. Plus… I have something special planned.”

Something in her tone made my stomach clench, but I pushed the feeling aside. “I’ll be there,” I promised, already mentally listing possible gift ideas. Maybe this was her way of trying to bridge the gap between us.

The following Saturday, I arrived at my parents’ house carrying two carefully wrapped packages—a high-end baby monitor and a handmade blanket. Despite our differences, this was my future niece or nephew. The place looked like a pastel explosion had hit it—pink and blue balloons everywhere, streamers hanging from every surface, and a towering diaper-cake centerpiece. Trust Sarah to turn this into an event. She’d invited what looked like half the town: Aunt Margaret was there with her daughters, Mom’s bridge-club friends occupied the sofa, and Sarah’s old college roommates clustered around the punch bowl, giggling over some shared memory.

“Time for games!” Sarah announced, wading through the crowd in a flowing maternity dress that probably cost more than my monthly rent. She was glowing, but there was something predatory in her smile that made me uneasy. Her eyes kept finding mine across the room, holding my gaze a beat too long.