I can still hear his voice as clearly as that afternoon while we stood in our new home in Mount Pleasant, South Carolina. The house was filled with the scent of fresh paint and empty boxes, yet the keys in my hand felt like a promise that had just withered away.

Two hours before that moment, we had finally signed the paperwork for the house at the local notary office. I had the legal folder and all the receipts tucked into my bag along with a silly sense of excitement about the future.

I was already imagining lace curtains on the windows and slow Sunday mornings cooking breakfast in our brand new kitchen. I truly believed I finally had something solid like a real home and a man I was supposed to marry in three months.

Then my phone started ringing and I saw that the caller was my younger sister, Melody. Melody was always the type of person who wanted things that didn’t belong to her, smiling while she calculated exactly how much she could take from others.

We hadn’t spoken in two months because she had borrowed money for an emergency only to post photos from a luxury resort in Cabo. I answered the call on a sudden impulse without thinking about the consequences of speaking to her.

“Sienna, please forgive me, but I just couldn’t keep this a secret any longer,” she said in a trembling voice that sounded far too rehearsed. “Garrett was going to tell you tonight, but I felt it was much better if you heard the truth directly from me.”

My blood ran cold as I gripped the phone tighter while standing in the middle of the empty foyer. “What are you talking about, Melody?” I asked with a sense of dread growing in my chest.

There was a small and cruel silence on the other end of the line before she finally spoke again. “I am pregnant, and Garrett is the father,” she whispered with a tone that suggested she was enjoying my pain.

I don’t remember breathing for several seconds after those words hit me like a physical blow. I just stared at the empty living room where the afternoon sun was streaming through the large windows.

“I don’t believe you,” I finally managed to say through my shock as I leaned against a stack of boxes. “It doesn’t matter if you believe me because he has been with me for months and he is going to take responsibility now,” she replied.